Why People Are Leaving MyFitnessPal
MyFitnessPal dominated calorie tracking for over a decade. But in 2022, Under Armour sold it off, and since then the complaints have piled up: paywalled features that used to be free, a bloated interface, a food database full of user-submitted errors, and calorie adjustments from exercise sync that routinely inflate your intake budget.
The app still works. But "works" is a low bar when better options exist.
Here are seven MyFitnessPal alternatives worth your attention in 2025 — ranked by use case.
1. Soma — Best for Gym-Goers Who Want Everything in One App
If you train and track nutrition, Soma is the most complete option available. It combines AI-powered workout programming, RPE-based training logs, and photo calorie tracking in a single app.
Why it beats MFP for gym-goers:
- Photo-based meal logging — snap your food, get macros instantly. No searching a database.
- Barcode scanner for packaged foods — fast, accurate, database-backed
- Training and nutrition in the same place — see how your food aligns with your training schedule
- AI-generated custom workout plan for every user — built to your goals and equipment, free
- Unlimited workout tracking, no caps
- AI coach that adapts your program based on actual performance data
- Social leaderboard for accountability
- All of the above on the free tier — more than any other app offers without paying
If you're lifting seriously and want your nutrition to actually connect to your training, MFP can't compete. Soma was built for this use case from the ground up.
Best for: Gym-goers, lifters, anyone who trains consistently
2. MacroFactor — Best for Precision Macro Tracking
MacroFactor is the most science-backed calorie tracking app available. Built by the team behind Stronger by Science, it uses an adaptive algorithm that calculates your actual TDEE from your logged food and weight trends — rather than relying on generic formulas.
Standout features:
- Adaptive expenditure algorithm (genuinely more accurate than static TDEE estimates)
- Clean, fast logging interface
- No ads, transparent subscription model
Limitations: No workout tracking. Steep learning curve for beginners. More suited to people who are already comfortable with nutrition concepts.
Best for: Data-driven trackers who want precision over simplicity
3. Cronometer — Best for Micronutrient Tracking
Cronometer goes deeper than macros — it tracks vitamins, minerals, and amino acids with unusually high accuracy. The food database is heavily verified, which means fewer errors than MFP's crowd-sourced entries.
Best for: Health-conscious users, anyone managing specific nutritional needs, people who want verified data over convenience
4. Lose It! — Most Similar to MyFitnessPal
If you want the closest substitute to MFP with a cleaner interface and fewer paywalls, Lose It! is the obvious choice. Large food database, barcode scanning, calorie goals, exercise logging — it's familiar territory.
Best for: People who just want a basic calorie counter that isn't MFP
5. Cal AI — Best for Pure Photo Tracking
Cal AI is a single-purpose app focused entirely on AI photo calorie estimation. Point your phone at a meal, get the macros. No workout features, no complex setup — just fast logging.
Limitations: No training integration, limited nutritional depth, and no adaptive features. It's a tool, not a system.
Best for: People who want the fastest possible food logging with no overhead
6. Carb Manager — Best for Low-Carb and Keto Diets
If you're tracking macros with a specific emphasis on carb limits — keto, low-carb, or diabetes management — Carb Manager has the most tailored experience. Net carb tracking, keto-specific recipes, and a large food database make it the top pick for this use case.
Best for: Keto and low-carb dieters
7. Nutritionix Track — Best for Chain Restaurant Data
Nutritionix has one of the largest verified restaurant and branded food databases in the world. The tracking app is free, reasonably fast, and especially good if you eat out a lot and need accurate chain restaurant data. It's a niche tool — useful for that specific use case.
Best for: People who eat at chain restaurants frequently and need reliable nutritional data for specific menu items
Which MFP Alternative Is Right for You?
| You want... | Use this |
|---|---|
| Training + nutrition in one app | Soma |
| Best free tier (calorie tracking, barcode scanner, AI plan — all free) | Soma |
| Maximum macro precision | MacroFactor |
| Micronutrient tracking | Cronometer |
| A simple MFP replacement | Lose It! |
| Just photo logging | Cal AI |
| Keto / low-carb focus | Carb Manager |
| Chain restaurant data | Nutritionix Track |
The Bottom Line
MyFitnessPal isn't bad — it's just no longer the best at what it does. The alternatives above are all purpose-built for specific use cases, and most are better at them than MFP.
If you're a regular gym-goer who trains and wants to track nutrition without switching between multiple apps, Soma is the move. It's the only app that takes both sides seriously.